One of the most fascinating activities dedicated to American-Jewish war dead of the two world wars in the 19th century is Operation Benjamin.
I came across Operation Benjamin in 2019 at the Normandy American cemetery at Colleville-sur-Mer. Here is what this organisation is all about.
Operation Benjamin`s mission statement
The mission of Operation Benhamin is to identify Jewish soldiers at American military cemeteries all over the world who were mistakenly buried under Latin Crosses and replace the headstones with a Star of David. This allows for accurate and just recognition of the soldier’s identity, provides comfort to the families of the fallen, and enables the millions of visitors to the American military cemeteries to visually understand and appreciate the shared Jewish sacrifice in the causes of democracy and freedom.
History of Operation Benjamin
It was in May 2014, shortly before the 70th anniversary of the D-Day landings in Normandy on June 6, 1944, that Rabbi Dr. Jacob J. Schacter, a faculty member at Yeshiva University in New York, visited the American military cemetery in Normandy in the French coastal town of Colleville-sur-Mer.
During this visit, Rabbi Schacter noticed that there were fewer Star of David headstones in the cemetery than he had expected. Only 149 graves were marked with a Star of David, 1.56% of the 9,388 graves in the cemetery. Something was wrong.
Approximately 550,000 American Jews served in the U.S. armed forces during World War II, about 3.4% of the 16 million U.S. armed forces personnel during World War II. This percentage was about the same as the Jewish percentage of the U.S. population at the time.
During the war, approximately 11,000 Jewish soldiers lost their lives, representing 2.7% of the 405,399 U.S. service personnel who made the ultimate sacrifice.
Of these 405,399, approximately 291,000 were killed in action (KIA) and a surprisingly high number of 114,000 were non-battle deaths (including accidents, disease, and other causes).
In the 14 American Battle Monuments Commission (ABMC) World War II cemeteries worldwide, 92,958 U.S. service members are buried. 91,098 of these graves are marked with a Latin cross and 1,860 with a Star of David (2.0%). The disparity between the percentage of Jewish fatalities (2.7%) and their percentage in the 14 ABMC WWII cemeteries (2.0%) is obvious.
Rabbi Schacter first turned to his friend Shalom Lamm, a businessman with a master's degree in American military history. As they began to investigate the mystery, it quickly became clear that the Jewish GIs were not missing after all - they were misidentified.
Rabbi Schacter and Lamm determined that there must be hundreds of Jewish soldiers buried under Latin crosses in various American military cemeteries around the world (assuming that the proportion of repatriated Jewish service personnel and Jewish service personnel missing in action is the same as for non-Jewish service personnel).
Correcting these errors is the goal of their campaign to right a decades-old wrong and ensure that the Jewish GIs who gave their lives for their country can finally rest in peace under the Star of David markers they would have wanted.
There are several reasons a Jewish soldier might be interred under a cross.
The first had to do with the process by which soldiers were temporarily buried near battlefields. Many of the GIs who were killed during the storming of the Normandy beach on D-Day in June 1944 or in the weeks to follow had to be hastily buried on the spot, then later reburied when military cemeteries were established in the region. The army made every effort to determine the identity of the deceased, but when soldiers had to be reburied multiple times, clerical errors sometimes ensued, especially if the GIs’ dog tags—which indicated religious affiliation—became separated from their bodies during battle and were lost.
A second explanation concerned the dog tags. They not only state the GI’s name, rank and serial number, but also bear the designation “P” for Protestant, “C” for Catholic or “H” for Hebrew, in order to ensure that the religious needs of a seriously wounded soldier are met, and that a deceased soldier’s burial rites are conducted in accordance with his faith. During World War II, some Jewish GIs requested a C or a P—or “N,” for no religious preference—for fear of persecution if they were taken prisoner by the Germans; others altered the H to resemble a P—or totally effaced the religious designation on the dog tag—shortly before going into battle.
They had good reason to be afraid; the Nazis did not respect conventional rules regarding treatment of captured enemy soldiers. Some American GIs were sent to the Buchenwald and Mauthausen concentration camps, instead of normal POW facilities. Several hundred US Jewish GIs who were among the American POWs brought to the Stalag IX-B prisoner camp in 1945 were separated from their comrades and sent to the Berga slave labor camp, a subcamp of Buchenwald; thirty-five of them were worked to death, and another thirty-six died on a death march from Berga before the arrival of the victorious Allied armies.
There is also evidence that some American Jewish soldiers may have requested a C or a P, or no designation, for fear of suffering discrimination at the hands of fellow soldiers if their Jewish identity became known. In her book GI Jews, Professor Deborah Dash Moore found that anti-Semitic incidents occurred frequently in the military in the World War II era, sometimes erupting into fistfights.
The team’s research found no evidence that the military authorities ever deliberately chose a cross to mark a grave of a soldier whom they knew to be Jewish. In every instance that mislabeled graves have been uncovered, human error, not malice, was the cause. Because their loved ones were buried in faraway Europe or the South Pacific, many surviving relatives never visited their graves and thus never knew about the crosses; or, if they knew, they did not realize the mistake could be corrected.
One important source of information for the team is to be found in the records of the Jewish Welfare Board, housed at the American Jewish Historical Society in New York City. Many parents of Jewish GIs in World War II filled out a JWB form providing basic family and biographical information so the Board could assist the GI in various ways during his service—for example, via the Jewish chaplains (such as Rabbi Schacter’s father, the late Rabbi Herschel Schacter) whom the JWB helped train. Cross-checking the JWB’s records with US military records of wartime casualties has yielded crucial information.
After confirming through an extensive documentary trail that a soldier who was Jewish is buried under a cross, the team moves into the phase of contacting surviving relatives. Legal next of kin are the only ones who have the authority to formally request that a grave marker be changed. The request is made to the government agency charged with caring for all foreign US military cemeteries, the American Battle Monuments Commission (ABMC). “A country must be judged by how it cares for those who gave their lives for it,” says ABMC leader Major General (ret.) William Matz, with whom Rabbi Schacter and his colleagues work closely in addressing these issues.
The foundation of Operation Benjamin
The team’s first success was the case of PFC Benjamin (Boruch) Garadetsky, who was killed in a German bombing of his position in France in August 1944. There was no doubt Garadetsky was Jewish; Shalom Lamm and his wife, Tina, had visited the Long Island graves of the GI’s parents and saw the Hebrew inscriptions on their headstones. Moreover, Garadetsky, who was born in Russia, and had written “Hebrew” under “race” on his 1941 application for American citizenship.
When the team tracked down Garadetsky’s nephew, a doctor in St. Louis, it turned out that the family was aware of the cross and had written to government officials about it many years earlier but had not pursued it. With help from Lamm and Lamar, an official request was submitted through the American Battle Monuments Commission and quickly approved.
On June 20, 2018, Lamar, Rabbi Schacter and dozens of friends and family members of the Garadetskys gathered at the Normandy cemetery for the solemn ceremony at which the cross was replaced by a Star of David. Tehillim were recited, family members shared reminiscences and Rabbi Schacter conducted a memorial ceremony that he created for the occasion; since there is no existing religious service for this uniquely modern occasion, the rabbi improvised. He concluded with the poignant declaration, “Benjamin, on behalf of the citizens of the United States of America, we thank you for making the ultimate sacrifice, and Benjamin, on behalf of the Jewish people, we welcome you home.”
To honor the namesake of their first successful mission, the team gave their campaign a permanent name: Operation Benjamin.
By January 2025, 27 marker replacements had taken place, three of them at the Normandy American Cemetery:
- Private First Class Benjamin Garadetsky
(Plot B, Row 14, Grave 6), Date of headstone change: June 20, 2018
- Sergeant Charles L. Solomon
(Plot D, Row 25, Grave 40), Date of headstone change: April 8, 2019
- 1st Lieutenant Lawrence S. Craig
(Plot E, Row 15, Grave 6), Date of headstone change: May 29, 2023
Why is it important for Jewish people to be buried under a Star of David grave marker?
In Jewish tradition, the Star of David (Magen David) is a widely recognized symbol of Jewish identity and heritage. While not a strict religious requirement, its presence on a headstone has deep cultural, spiritual, and communal significance. Here’s why it is important for many Jewish people to have a Star of David on their headstone:
1. Identity and Belonging
• The Star of David publicly affirms the deceased’s Jewish faith and heritage.
• It connects them to the Jewish people, past and present, in life and death.
2. Symbol of Protection and Divine Connection
• The Star of David has been historically associated with divine protection.
• Some interpret its two interlocking triangles as a representation of the connection between God and the Jewish people.
3. Continuity and Memory
• Jewish tradition places great emphasis on remembering the deceased (Yizkor, Kaddish, and visiting graves).
• The Star of David serves as a clear marker that the person was part of the Jewish faith, ensuring their memory is honored accordingly.
4. Cemetery and Community Tradition
• Many Jewish cemeteries use the Star of David to distinguish Jewish graves.
• It helps maintain the sacredness and separation of Jewish burial grounds from non-Jewish sections.
5. Halachic Considerations
• While Jewish law (Halacha) primarily focuses on the proper burial process rather than specific markers, using Jewish symbols on a gravestone aligns with customs of kavod hamet (respect for the deceased).
6. A Symbol of Jewish Resilience
• The Star of David has also been a symbol of Jewish survival, especially post-Holocaust, where marking Jewish graves became an act of preserving identity and defying erasure.
While not all Jewish graves must have a Star of David, it is a meaningful tradition for many families, ensuring that their loved ones' Jewish identity is honored in perpetuity.
Operation Levi – A New Project
Operation Benjamin is devoted to preserving the memories of American-Jewish soldiers who made the ultimate sacrifice while defending the cause of freedom during World War II.
In a brand-new initiative, Operation Benjamin has teamed up with the German War Graves Commission (Volksbund Deutsche Kriegsgräberfürsorge or VDK) and supports a project called “Operation Levi”.
“Operation Levi” is devoted to the memory of German Jewish soldiers who fell in the service of Germany in the First World War. The mission of Operation Levi is to identify Jewish soldiers buried in WWI German cemeteries around the world mistakenly buried under Latin Crosses and replace their headstones with Jewish monuments.
Operation Levi is named for Levi Meier from Bornheim, Germany who fell on December 29, 1917. He was the son of Isaac Levi and Rebecca Silberberg and was a Landsturmmann in the German Imperial Army and is buried under a cross at the Warmeriville German Cemetery in Northern France.
Operation Levi has identified over seven hundred such cases, like that of Levi Meier from Bornheim, of German Jewish soldiers from World War One that made the ultimate sacrifice for their country but were mistakenly buried under Latin Crosses. There is now an appeal to the greater German-Jewish and Jewish genealogical community to assist in connecting with any surviving family, cousins, descendants, distant relatives of these brave warriors so that they can participate in the process of giving the ultimate honor to these Jewish fallen. The names of the 700 men in question can be found at the gedenkportal website of the Volksbund, see link to their website below.
100,000 Germans of the Jewish faith were enlisted during the war, 12,000 of whom were to fall. Of the 500,000 named German soldiers of the First World War buried in France, 3,000 of these war dead were of the Jewish faith. In 1968, the leadership of the Volksbund (German War Graves Commission), in conjunction with the Central Council Of Jews and the Rabbinical Conference in Germany, decided to mark the graves of these dead with stelae. In addition to an engraving of the Star of David and the personal details of the deceased, these stelae also bear a Hebrew inscription, which translates as: “May his soul be bound up in the circle of the living.”